Role Description
We are searching for a performance-focused maven with deep social roots who understands the intricacies of production and ad creation. This individual will master creative strategy, social analytics, and creative direction of both actual production (shoots) and post (editing) to lead the agency's approval process. While our Strategy Team Lead manages daily strategist operations, we require a specialized role with direction that goes beyond standard management.
The ideal candidate serves as the ultimate bridge within the studio. You possess the social expertise to craft compelling briefs, the technical production knowledge to ensure they are executable, and the refined aesthetic judgment to distinguish exceptional ads from merely good ones. More importantly, you can provide the actionable feedback necessary to elevate the team's work.
Operating at the nexus of platform intelligence, production, and strategy, you will act as our creative conscience. Your mission is to establish high standards, develop the systems that maintain them, and guarantee that every piece of content produced by Creative Milkshake is a source of collective pride.
What you’ll do
-
Own creative quality, end to end
-
Set and hold the creative standard for all output - from storyboard to final ad
-
Review and give specific, actionable feedback on Creative Strategy Presentations (CSPs), storyboards, RAW footage, and final ads before they reach clients
-
Build and maintain the checklists, brand guides, and review frameworks that keep quality consistent as the team grows
-
Develop an ad example library and “what makes a great UGC ad” resource - codifying instinct into something the whole team can learn from
-
Be the bridge between strategy and production
-
Translate creative briefs into production-executable direction, and translate what’s possible on set back into strategy
-
Run pre-production alignment sessions between Creative Strategists and Producers so we go into every shoot prepared, not reactive
-
Identify where handoffs break down and build the processes to fix them
-
Be the person each department comes to when they’re not sure what the other team needs
-
Drive platform & trend intelligence
-
Maintain a genuine, current pulse on social platforms (e.g. TikTok and Meta) - what formats are performing, what hooks are landing, what’s oversaturated
-
Feed trend intelligence to the Creative Strategy team in a way that’s actionable, not just inspirational
-
Bring a production lens to trends: not just “what’s working” but “how do we make that in our studio?
-
Use AI tools as a natural part of ideation, scripting, and research workflows
-
Support key client creative relationships
-
Take the lead on creative input for a subset of VIP or complex client accounts
-
Join brainstorming and kick-off sessions where the creative direction needs a senior voice
-
Help the accounts team set accurate creative expectations with clients upfront - reducing revision cycles before they’ve started
-
Represent Creative Milkshake externally
-
Own approval of CM’s own social content and website portfolio - holding ourselves to the same standard we set for our clients
-
Shape what we show the world: the work we feature, the voice we use, the story we tell about what we make
Qualifications
-
4–8 years in performance creative, creative strategy, or content production - at a social-first agency, DTC brand, or UGC studio
-
Experience across both creative strategy and production
-
Deep, current relationship with TikTok and Meta
-
Ability to distinguish a good ad from a great one and explain the difference
-
Comfortable building processes and reviewing scripts
-
High EQ and collaborative instincts
-
Comfortable with ambiguity and fast pace
-
Fluent in English and confident presenting creative rationale to clients
Benefits
-
Standard Creative Milkshake Stipends (mental health, healthcare & internet)
-
Time Off: 21 days PTO + 7 Paid Sick Days; company closure: 2 weeks at year-end (estimated: December 22 – January 5)
-
Maternity/Paternity Leave
-
Yearly Salary Review
-
Long Service Incentives (starting from 2 years)